• Register

« L'homme c'est rien — l'oeuvre c'est tout. » Je suis né et je vis à Babylone, là où les enfants tuent, dealent et volent...

  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
  • View media
RSS My Blogs

In other words, some of the pitfalls of game development. As an addendum to the previous blog post: Moddb.com

***


Underestimating quantity

Quantity builds up quality. What is the difference between a quality mesh and a poorly made, blocky mesh? (Unintentionally low quality, not purposely lowpoly art, naturally!) The number of polygons. Yes, the number itself, not just the way the mesh is made. What is the real difference between a replayable game and a game that you can finish just once or that game you don't even want to finish just once? The number of possibilities, storyline or gameplay branches, numbers of enemies, levels, secrets, achievements... and more. (More, as in other things contribute to that irreplayability. Bad controls for example. Who can play a game with nasty controls for more than a few minutes? Only masochists or extreme e-sport fans, mayhap?)

So. Why play an unreplayable game?

Quantity makes up quality. Quite a chunk of indie developers choose to completely ignore that fact, and use that "quality over quantity" clichéd mantra as an excuse to avoid going an extra mile to give their own playerbase more content. The capitalistic "less is more" motto is extremely hostile to your players, and they can feel it when their money does not exactly equal purchased value. Aye, "less is more" is a good thing when you think about bugs and needless feature creep, YET it is truly something terrible when you consider cutting the number of levels, enemies, factions, perks, bosses, useful features, and so on. "Less is less" then, not "less is more". Gamerskind, pretty much like a Zerg hive mind, can feel someone is messing with them by giving them less content than planned or promised.

Too long indie GDDs never served anyone too well. Immensely important to know your limits, yes... immensely important to go an extra mile, however, too...

***


Giving up only after one failure and treating game development more like a hobby, not a real job

Game development is a job, you are supposed to continue developing games, not naively believe that your first game will be a huge hit. Stopping at just one single game is, well, preposterous. Continuing to make them, that should be the real purpose. Gamers hate developers who are only into it for money instead of being in it for both funds and passion. Real passion does not burn out after one failed game. Also to note, relying only on motivation may end badly. Game development, just like any other artistic activity, is like a fight, there is no good or bad mood for it, you have to push and continue it even when you dislike it.

Never give up if you really want to be a game developer.

***


Completely and totally ignoring the community's opinion while pretending to listen to feedback

Developers just like artists of any kind have the ultimate right to not give a damn about any players' opinions just like painters are free to ignore any suggestions made by their gallery viewers, freedom of creativity and all that jazz after all, but some issues may prove downright dangerous to ignore. Difficulty is one of them. Leaving critical bugs, scratch that off, no, many devs care about critical bugs, leaving less essential yet still annoying bugs as they are tends to be dangerous as well, just in the long run not the short run. Gamers can remember or recall better a company with bad reputation than the one with good one. Aaaaand to quote a certain artist, "Trifles make perfection, and perfection is no trifle". (Even when total pedantic perfectionism seems to be a bad idea too!)

***


Dishonest or only half-honest alpha and beta testers

Horrifying lack of objective, third party testers that can give you an honest opinion about your game. Just a couple of indie devs (and many more than a bunch of modders) feel insulted when someone constructively criticises their work, never realising that sometimes criticism is a blessing, especially when taken professionally, not personally. The above freedom of artistic expression blah blah still remains valid though, as an artist, nobody can compel you to do or make anything, it is simply safer to avoid implementing sucky things, you see, and criticism is supposed to weed out those sucky things... you see... criticism should always be valued. (Not just valued. Valued as in listened to.)

***


Letting your team members slack off

Projects either stagnate and die if left undeveloped for too long, or they are of less quality when shelved out for players. Unforgiving passage of time and the recidivist advent of new technology relentlessly beats crap out of those who dare to lag behind, too. Either way, if you let your team members do nothing for the project and you do not set an example by doing something of note (leader's example) or with your wallet (employer's example), then sorry, lions led by a sheep will get nowhere, and if your team members just laze around and only attend dev meetings, you can say goodbye to your dream game.

***


Treating alphafund/early access games as "released" games and thus requiring less attention

This is what plagued most alpha-funded games available on Steam's (ok, Valve's) Early Access. They were nuked by the community because developers suddenly found out how public pressure bores intolerably into them, barring them from further progress. So they just stick a "mission accomplished" and "not early access anymore" status on the game, when it did not even go through the beta phase properly. Remedy? If you care about reviews, you would have to take down your store page, and relaunch it when you are ready to roll out new updates polishing whatever needs polishing and fixing whatever needs fixing. Another way, while keeping the store page up, is to tie yourself to the chair, lock the door, severe the connection to the internet... no, not in that order... just to do one thing: to bear with external "fan" pressure that you (successfully) blocked out in the end i.e. started developing desperately needed updates for your game instead of hiding under the table away from the overly loud thunder of community.

***


Do you enjoy playing your own game? Do you REALLY enjoy playing your own game?

Take a step back. How does your game look? How does it play? Turn off cameras to stop recording gameplay, and play it purely for your enjoyment, just for a long while, not for youtubers, just for yourself. Did you truly enjoy the game? Most relatively bad games are born that way because that kind of developers fly through the game and play it solely as its developers and never or rarely care to play it as a bit more demanding gamers. How many hours can you play your game before you had enough?...

... you can expect most of your players to play at least around 1/8, 1/4 of that amount, depending on the game content, replayability and dynamic or key mechanics of your game.

Start a group Groups
Unreal Engine 4 Games

Unreal Engine 4 Games

695 members Fans & Clans

Group for all fans, gamers, modders and developers of Unreal Engine 4 games.

Indie Gamers

Indie Gamers

1,512 members Hobbies & Interests

For fans of indie games and hardcore indie gamers, no matter whether these indies are commercial or freeware/opensource. This hub used for many indie...

Indie Devs

Indie Devs

1,662 members Hobbies & Interests

A group dedicated to indie and standalone game development.

Unity Games

Unity Games

1,818 members Hobbies & Interests

For all Unity developers and developers-to-be, both beginners and professionals!

Cat lovers

Cat lovers

614 members Fans & Clans

This is a group for everyone who likes cats, and wanna have a look at some cute/funny cats.

Anime Fans of DBolical

Anime Fans of DBolical

488 members Fans & Clans

Rules for the group can be read on the front part of the group, questions can be sent to Kark-Jocke or you can comment at the front page of the group.

Anime Fans of modDB

Anime Fans of modDB

2,414 members Fans & Clans

This group has been formed to gather the people who enjoy Japanese anime and all of its facets, to salute the people from the land of the Rising Sun.

PC Gamers

PC Gamers

743 members Hardware & Tech

This is a group for all PC gamers from all gaming generations. From the time of PCs like the Comadore 64 to the modern PCs. By PC i don't mean just Windows...

Comments  (0 - 10 of 1,426)
MostSavory
MostSavory

I saw that I should bother you instead of the creator!
Please help me! My game disappeared literally while I was in the middle of updating it. Maybe some sort of bug?
I honestly can't remember if I cursed, but if that's the case I understand, but could somebody just tell me why? Or like if that's what happened?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Guest
Guest

Could you please unclose my account that i requested at first to be closed? moddb.com/members/the-adventurer

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
OrangeNero
OrangeNero

Sorry for the rude awakening. You take no blame in this.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
OrangeNero
OrangeNero

feillyne

Hey, if one made a tabletop or card game, what would be the best way to add it to this place?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+1 vote
feillyne CreatorSubscriber
feillyne

Community groups: Moddb.com

Reply Good karma+3 votes
OrangeNero
OrangeNero

Yeah I thought so, thanks for reassuring me :)
By the way, people should use this @ feature more often. Maybe make it automatically appear when one clicks on reply?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
Paul-F1
Paul-F1

Happy New Year! :)

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
Kark-Jocke
Kark-Jocke

I'm here again to wish you a happy new year feillyne! ( Moddb.com )

Reply Good karma Bad karma+3 votes
NaikJoy
NaikJoy

Thank you for Dusk of Glory.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
feillyne CreatorSubscriber
feillyne

You're welcome. And well, I am pretty much wrapped up in official, paid ModDB/IndieDB stuff... the admining kind of stuff... gosh... i'd like to return to non-assuming modding projects so much...

Reply Good karma+2 votes
Post a comment
Sign in or join with:

Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) and join in the conversation.

Level
Avatar
Avatar
Last Online
Country
Poland 🇵🇱
Gender
Male
Friends
Become friends
Member watch
Follow
DBolicalDesuraIndie DB
Statistics
Rank
1 of 705,045
Time Online
1 year
Activity Points
92,124
Watchers
135 members
Comments
6,055
Tags
7
Site visits
111,766
Contact
Contact
Send Message
Steam
feillyne
Playstation Network
feillyne
Skype
feillyne
Twitter

Latest tweets from @feillyne

Geistkrieg - A Shadow Over Egypt - THE new gem from the creators of MidEast Crisis 2 Moddb.com #modlove2015

May 24 2015

Yay, now Unity 4 supports normal maps for terrain textures... O.o

Nov 14 2012

RT @jesawyer: firaxis pls make a fantasy version of XCOM set in cimmeria called XCROM: riddle of steel. thx. ~*

Oct 22 2012

Awesome ambient loops on Looperman Looperman.com composed by Planetjazzbass

Jun 19 2012

Awesome news - Unity3d comes to Linux in its latest incarnation, Unity 4! Can be pre-ordered at Unity3d.com

Jun 19 2012

Friends
Seamus.Editor
Seamus.Editor Online
DarkMajor21
DarkMajor21 Online
Beskamir
Beskamir Online
Sarge_Rho
Sarge_Rho Online
xonone
xonone Online
Jason_Zombolt
Jason_Zombolt Online
DabsterEnt
DabsterEnt Online
FekLeyrTarg
FekLeyrTarg Online
Metaltooth
Metaltooth Online
SPY-maps
SPY-maps Online