I think realistic is better unless the game calls for over the top violence. Some games such as Quake 3 use gore as part of their gameplay, but games like half-life 2, where realism is one of the keys to its brilliant gameplay needs much more toned down gore. The amount of gore should just depend on the game. I like all types of gore (except SOF, i think that just took it to the extreme) but i would hate to see Quake 3 style gibbing in half-life 2, that would just ruin the game. The gore should depend on the type of gameplay the game wants to offer. But I prefer realistic because it makes it so much more believable, and that makes me question the game less and just enjoy it. Other people may disagree, but to each his own.
Raptor73
joined
This member has provided no bio about themself...