Reviews - TheSniperFan

9/10 is a very high score, but I honestly think this game deserves it.
Yes, The Dark Descent is the better horrorgame. Yes, the gameplay of TDD is better. However, while the horror and gameplay of A Machine For Pigs are inferior, the story, the level-, audio- and visualdesign are superior.
Thus I don't think there is a clear answer to the question which game is better. It all comes down on whether - for the individual player - its strengths make up for its shortcomings or not.
Since I am a gamer with great interest in videogame stories, for me they do. Though I can fully understand why one might think otherwise.
For me it's the same situation as with Portal and Antichamber. I think Portal (AMFP) is the better game; I like it more; It's a much better crafted experience. I think that Antichamber (TDD) is the better puzzlegame (horrorgame) though; It excells at what makes games of its genre great.

Or in short:
For me A Machine For Pigs is the better game, while The Dark Descent is the better horrorgame.

It's my favourite engine, so why do I give it only 8 points? Not because it does not have the best graphics or something like that. Content-quality is something that you should find in game-reviews, not the ones for the engine.
I give it only 8 points because it is a pain in the a** to use. Why do I have to sit through a long (map)compile before I can see if I changed the brightness-value of one single lighting-enity correctly? Why can't I add materials via drag and drop and edit its properties in realtime? Besides that it's really getting old. I don't need graphics and such big maps like Dunia has, but with Source I have to cut big maps into small ones or I run into its limits if I make it detailled. Look at Cinematic Mod. It pushes Source beyond its limits and still looks crappy against Crysis, while having much higher system-requirements. That's one of the cases where you see how old Source is and that it wasn't made for the quality-standards of 2011. The standards raise faster than Source. Back then, when Source got relased, it was unbelivable that it has Radiosity, now games do that in realtime. Just as lighting. "But Portal 2...", you might say. Portal 2 still has not "real" realtime lighting, because props still arent lit properly and you still have to compile.

This review is not to bash VALVe or Source, I am trying to be objective here, because I hate people that defend Source in points where it is just stupid to do so. It's time to stop being a fanboy, stop being biased and just go on.