• Register

Design and build the most efficient metro stations known to man! Excavate. Expand. Set staff priorities. And manage the commuter flow. Overcrowd is a management/tycoon/simulator set below the bustling city of Lubdon Town.

Post news RSS Overcrowd: A Commute 'Em Up - Devblog 12

An update on my progress with Overcrowd: A Commute 'Em Up, a pausable RTS/management sim/basebuilder set on the London underground.

Posted by on

So what’s been happening with Overcrowd: A Commute 'Em Up? In short, many aspects have been improved, bug-fixed, re-written, re-specced, revitalised or revised. There’s a new GUI. The entire system of staff control has been improved/redone. Commuter AI has been improved. Most importantly, the way the game is really going to work has crystallised for me too.

Sure there was always a plan, but now there is an overarching structure to the game, including a map you unlock, persistent staff, and a tech shop where you can access new tools and items.

Let me explain, because I’ve decided to say a bit more about what this game might end up like. While there is an open play mode (currently) – where you build as you go, expand, and deal with what happens, the thrust of the game is more in the so-called campaign mode.

Here you see a tube map, and starting in the outer zones you visit a station (level), where you have a set challenge (eg. Shift X commuters in Y days). You get a budget, a play area with different rock formations, and predetermined (multiple) track positions and entrance possibilities, meaning you have to decide what you think the best station design for that play area is with your given budget.

When you complete a station you unlock more staff to choose from, and more tech contracts which are spent on the campaign screen to unlock better tools and more efficient facilities to build in game. So maybe you want to unlock a bigger plant to make people happier (plants make people happy right?), or buy a more efficient power generator to use at your next station. This could evolve into a fully-fledged tech tree further down the line. Later you can unlock longer trains too.

You also take your staff with you between stations. Staff learn skills as you use them, so they get better at doing certain things. When you take them to the next station, you can use them on the jobs they are best at. Hopefully in the future you’ll be able to change staff names or nicknames.

After one station is unlocked you can visit the next one on the line. The aim is to make it to the centre. There are multiple routes, so you can go different ways, perhaps choosing to unlock more tech or staff at easier stations, levelling and training your team as you go, before visiting higher zone stations which are harder. A station challenge can be failed if your reputation (determined by how happy your commuters have been) hits zero, or if you run out of time.

Overcrowd Screen 2

It’s a cliché but I find it hard to pigeon-hole the game. From the screenshots, you might expect a hands off “management” game. But it’s not really that. Controlling staff is hands on and pretty granular, and the game is actually fairly tactical and tense. You deploy your staff to areas and equip them with the tools they need, and you set their priorities. You have to react and decide who responds to what when problems crop up. And you have to make sure workers are well-rested and nourished in the staff room.

These aspects of Overcrowd are similar to a pausable real-time-strategy game, where instead of fighting an enemy, you are fighting the degradation of your station (when technician skills are added anyway), littering, and various types of commuter behaviour.

Overcrowd staff room

But you’re also building your station for good commuter flow, plus you have the option of ushering commuters through choke points if you want to use your staff like that, which doesn’t really have an equivalent in RTS. The fact you can unlock new tech and items to build too is more akin to traditional builders.

You have to think about the station environment too. This means being conscious of space. Space is money, and the more space, the less crowding and easier it will be to play. Space is convenience to your commuters too: where is the best place for that one bin you can afford so that it is close enough for commuters to use between two platforms? Where should you place your power generators, which produce harmful fumes, when space is at a premium? The potential future addition of heat simulation will further add to the environment considerations.

And then you need to watch your money, not least because staff need to be paid. But you can earn more from shops (if you have unlocked them), so you have to decide on restocking levels and price points. Later down the line, shops may have functional uses too: maybe coffee will speed up your commuters allowing you to transport more over time.

Overcrowd Screen 3

Finally, I’m planning on making some of the challenges on the map somewhat or entirely procedural, meaning that it’s also a rogue-like, er, station-builder with high replayability.

We’ll see! I think everything should be fluid in the game design and that’s why Overcrowd will go into Steam Early access: nothing is set in stone. It will be good to get there. Hope you can join me!


Make a Discord?

Reply Good karma Bad karma0 votes
ph_101 Author

I'm not a regular use, but maybe I'll look into it when I hit steam early access.

Reply Good karma+1 vote

I came into this article expecting to feel like this would be a decent game. Now that I've read it, though, I can say I'm positively surprised and waiting to try this game out as soon as I can.

Maybe it's the way you sold it to me, but the granular aspects of staff control and redirecting crowds of commuters seem like they will make for a much more satisfying system than most RTS games I've played, since even in city-builders (or park-builders) there's always a feeling that I can't control how things work on a micro level and that once I deploy staff or build strutures they are mostly self-sufficient beings - and I have either made a Good Move or a Bad Move, and only removing such units completely can actually impact my game anymore.

What I feel isn't necessarily true, by the way. I just suck **** at RTS games.

But your project seems different indeed and I think I will enjoy trying to get good at it. So congratulations on your hard work!

- Lucas

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
ph_101 Author

Hiya Lucas

Thanks for your comment, it's interesting to read. Yeah making this game seems like in some areas it's a going to be a balancing act between the degrees of direct control given to the player vs staff/facility autonomony (leaving aside the building aspects).

It's quite encouraging to hear your point of view - I expect others might prefer a more hands off approach as seen in the traditional management game model. I guess its a question of where the players attention lies. Hopefully it will end up a reasonable mix of them both, and I'll be refining through beta/early access anyway.

On the RTS difficulty side, you can pause/unpause any time with space bar, so although it can be hectic, you can take time to think - I'm sort of aiming for an FTL vibe there dare I say. That carries through with staff (currently) learning what jobs they do so you can specialise them.

I figure there are plenty of amazing management/tycoon games out there, I suppose I would rather attempt something marginally different and see how it works out. Like I said, certain approaches are still quite fluid, so we'll see how it all pans out! Thanks again for your thoughts - hopefully I can bring you more updates and play through vids in the coming months!

Reply Good karma+2 votes

Awesome. Looking forward to that!

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes

Just found out about this project now, and it looks extremely interesting. I am always fascinatedon past prototypes to see the evolution of the project from the initial idea until release.

In Dev Log 1 you mention that the project was already in dev for more than a year, so it's back in 2013 or so... how did it look like at the time? and did you drastically steer away from the initial design?

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
ph_101 Author

Hiya. Thanks for checking out the game. Yes Overcrowd has actually changed a large amount since then! Initially it was much smaller in scope, focused just on controlling units around premade stations. Since then it has probably been 80% rewritten, allowing the whole building of stations, shops and different staff mechanics, but the core actions of ushering commuters and managing litter, the commuter fighting and vomiting behaviours have remained, as has the theme and (generally) the art style/humour. You can see how the 2013 prototype looks in the (old) trailer on youtube, which has the old GUI present. So yeah it has drastically changed. This was because I realised I wanted to devote more time to it and make it a much bigger/deeper experience. During that time I also learnt essentially to code (beyond mere basics!), which meant I could make the game match my goals more easily. Hope you continue to watach for further updates in the future.

Reply Good karma+2 votes

Thanks a lot for your answer. These are great insights. I'm glad you stick to your guns with the vomiting behavior! :D
I wish you good luck, and will look forward to future updates.

Reply Good karma Bad karma+2 votes
ph_101 Author

Don't fear on that score - vomit will be always be a feature in Overcrowd :)

Reply Good karma+1 vote
Post a comment
Sign in or join with:

Only registered members can share their thoughts. So come on! Join the community today (totally free - or sign in with your social account on the right) and join in the conversation.

Follow Profile
Overcrowd: A Commute 'Em Up
Squareplay Games
Send Message
Release date
Game watch
Dev blog
Post news
Related Games
Related Engines
GameMaker Studio
GameMaker Studio Commercial
Related Groups
Indie Devs
Indie Devs Hobbies & Interests
Indie Gamers
Indie Gamers Hobbies & Interests
Squareplay Games
Squareplay Games Developer